APPSC Group-II Screening (Prelims) 2018 · Q 65
The President of India cannot proclaim National Emergency under Article 352 in the entire country or in any part of it, on the ground of
- (a) War
- (b) External Aggression
- (c) Armed Rebellion
- (d) Internal Disturbance
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D): 'internal disturbance' ceased to be a ground for a National Emergency when the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 replaced it with 'armed rebellion'. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) War — War is a valid ground under Article 352. If India is at war with another country, the President can proclaim a National Emergency for the whole country or any part of it. The 1962 Emergency (during the China war) and the 1971 Emergency (during the Pakistan war) were both proclaimed on this ground. So the President is not barred here. • ✅ (B) External Aggression — External aggression means an attack or threat of attack from outside India. It is a valid ground under Article 352, even if war has not been formally declared. The 1971 Emergency was proclaimed on the twin grounds of external aggression and war. Hence the President is not barred here either. • ✅ (C) Armed Rebellion…
APPSC Group-II Screening (Prelims) 2016 — General Studies · Q 33
In which case did the Supreme Court deliver the landmark judgement dealing with imposition of President's Rule in the States ?
- (a) Minerva Mills
- (b) Golaknath
- (c) Maneka Gandhi
- (d) S.R. Bommai
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D): S.R. Bommai is the landmark case because it subjected the imposition of President's Rule under Article 356 to judicial review and laid down concrete procedural safeguards. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) — Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980) was about the basic structure doctrine and Article 31C. It struck down parts of the 42nd Amendment. It did not deal with President's Rule under Article 356. • ❌ (B) — Golaknath v. State of Punjab (1967) held that fundamental rights cannot be abridged by a constitutional amendment. It was about Article 13 and the amending power. It has no link to President's Rule. • ❌ (C) — Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978) expanded Article 21. It held that personal liberty can be curtailed only by a fair, just and reasonable procedure. It was not about Article 356 or President's Rule. • ✅ (D) — S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) is t…
APPSC Group-II Screening (Prelims) 2016 — General Studies · Q 43
President's Rule is declared under which Article of the Constitution ?
- (a) Article 352
- (b) Article 360
- (c) Article 358
- (d) Article 356
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D): President's Rule is declared under Article 356, because only this Article deals with the failure of constitutional machinery in a State. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Article 352 — Article 352 deals with National Emergency. It can be proclaimed only on grounds of war, external aggression or armed rebellion, and it affects the whole country — not a single State's constitutional machinery. President's Rule is a State-level breakdown, so 352 is the wrong choice. • ❌ (B) Article 360 — Article 360 provides for Financial Emergency. Here the President acts when the financial stability or credit of India (or of any part of it) is threatened. India has never proclaimed a Financial Emergency, but 360 is still distinct from President's Rule under 356. • ❌ (C) Article 358 — Article 358 is a special provision that suspends the six freedoms of Article 19 when a National Emerg…
APPSC Group-II Screening (Prelims) 2016 — General Studies · Q 71
Even during Emergency, the following rights cannot be suspended:
- (a) Right under Article 14
- (b) Right under Article 21
- (c) Right under Article 22
- (d) Right under Article 19
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): among the options, only Article 21 is shielded from suspension, because the proviso to Article 359(1), inserted by the 44th Amendment Act 1978, bars any Presidential order suspending the enforcement of Articles 20 and 21. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Right under Article 14 — Article 14 (equality before law) is a fundamental right, but it is not protected by the proviso to Article 359(1). So the President can, by order, suspend the right to move any court for its enforcement during a National Emergency. Only Articles 20 and 21 are kept outside that power. • ✅ (B) Right under Article 21 — The 44th Amendment Act, 1978 added a proviso to Article 359(1): the President may not suspend the right to move any court for the enforcement of the rights conferred by Articles 20 and 21. Article 21 (protection of life and personal liberty) therefore survives every Emergency. T…