APPSC Group-I Prelims 2022 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 37
What is/are the provision(s) to safeguard the autonomy of the Supreme Court of India? I. While appointing the Supreme Court Judges, the President of India has to consult the Chief Justice of India. II. The Supreme Court Judges can be removed by the Chief Justice of India only. III. The salaries of the Judges are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India on which the legislature does not have to vote. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) I and II only
- (b) II and III only
- (c) I and III only
- (d) I, II and III
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): only statements I and III hold, because the Constitution protects judicial autonomy through mandatory consultation with the CJI for appointments and by charging the judges' salaries on the non-votable Consolidated Fund of India, while removal needs a special parliamentary address, not the CJI alone. Statement-by-statement analysis • ✅ I — Article 124(2) says the President appoints Supreme Court judges after consulting the Chief Justice of India and other judges he thinks necessary. The proviso adds that for appointing a judge other than the Chief Justice, the CJI 'shall always be consulted'. This mandatory consultation is a safeguard against executive favouritism. For the Chief Justice's own appointment, the President appoints, but the seniority convention protects independence. So statement I is correct. • ❌ II — A Supreme Court judge cannot be removed by the Chief…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2022 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 38
Which of the following are not included in the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court? I. A dispute between two or more States. II. A dispute regarding elections to either House of the Parliament or that of Legislature of a State. III. A dispute between the Government of India and a Union Territory. IV. A dispute between the Government of India and one or more States. Choose the correct answer using the codes given below:
- (a) I and II
- (b) II and III
- (c) III and IV
- (d) I and IV
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): II and III are not included, because Article 131 covers the Union and the States (and States among themselves), while election disputes go to High Courts and a Union Territory is not a State. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — A dispute between two or more States is included in the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction under Article 131, if it involves a question of law or fact on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. So I is not one of the 'not included' items. • ✅ II — A dispute regarding elections to either House of Parliament or a State legislature is not decided by the Supreme Court in its original jurisdiction. Article 329(b) bars court interference in electoral matters except by an election petition, and under the Representation of the People Act, 1951 such petitions go to the High Court. So II is not included. • ✅ III — Article 131 nam…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 31
Choose the correct answer relating to the Supreme Court of India:
- (a) The Supreme Court has the autonomy to make rules for the practice and procedure of the court.
- (b) The President can transfer judges of the Supreme Court at his own discretion.
- (c) Decisions of the Supreme Court are not binding on the High Courts.
- (d) Parliament alone frames the rules of procedure for the Supreme Court.
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): under Article 145(1) the Supreme Court may itself make rules for its practice and procedure (with the President's formal approval), while (B) confuses High Court transfer with Supreme Court judges, (C) contradicts Article 141, and (D) wrongly hands the rule-making power to Parliament. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) The Supreme Court has the autonomy to make rules for the practice and procedure of the court. — Article 145(1) says the Supreme Court may, with the approval of the President, make rules for regulating generally the practice and procedure of the Court. Notice the cause-and-effect: the Court itself frames the rules — it is not waiting for Parliament — so the Court keeps real autonomy; the President's approval is only a formal check, not control. So this option correctly describes the position. • ❌ (B) The President can transfer judges of the Supreme Cour…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 150
In which of the following issues did the Supreme Court invoke Article 142 of the Constitution to issue directions in a judgment in a case in 2016 ?
- (a) Constitutional validity of Defamation Act
- (b) Regulatory mechanism for legal profession
- (c) Right of disabled people to live with dignity
- (d) Ban on licenses to liquor shops near State and National Highways
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D): in State of Tamil Nadu v. K. Balu (2016), the Supreme Court used Article 142 to ban liquor licences within 500 metres of national and state highways. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Constitutional validity of Defamation Act — In 2016 the Supreme Court upheld criminal defamation in Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India. The Court tested IPC Sections 499 and 500 under Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(2). It did not issue directions under Article 142 on a ‘Defamation Act’. • ❌ (B) Regulatory mechanism for legal profession — The Supreme Court has often discussed the Bar Council of India’s regulatory role in legal education and professional conduct. But the 2016 Article 142 direction in question was not about creating a regulatory mechanism for the legal profession. • ❌ (C) Right of disabled people to live with dignity — In Jeeja Ghosh v. Union of India (2016), the Court strongl…