APPSC Group-I Prelims 2024 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 60
Which of the following statement/statements is/are valid with respect to the Preamble of the Indian Constitution?
I. The term 'democratic' as used in the Preamble is a mix of British Fabian Socialism and American Populism.
II. The term 'Republic' in the Preamble indicates that India has an elected head, called the Prime Minister.
III. The 'Liberty' expressed in the Preamble is neither absolute nor qualified.
IV. The term 'Fraternity' as used by the Preamble, originally denoted the dignity of the individual only.
Select the correct answer using the codes given below:
- (a) Only I
- (b) II and III
- (c) Only IV
- (d) None
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D) None, because every one of the four statements carries a factual error — Republic means the elected President not the Prime Minister, Liberty in the Preamble is qualified by its own five spheres, Fraternity covers both individual dignity and national unity, and 'democratic' is not a Fabian–American populist mix. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — The word 'democratic' in the Preamble means that the government draws its authority from the will of the people ('We, the people of India'). It stands for political democracy (elections, universal adult franchise, rule of law), social democracy (equality, liberty, fraternity as ends) and economic democracy (the Directive Principles). No constitution text or standard commentary describes 'democratic' as a blend of British Fabian Socialism and American Populism. Fabian, Marxist and Gandhian strands are discussed, if at al…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2022 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 45
Consider the following statements: I. The Preamble was enacted before the enactment of the entire Constitution. II. The Preamble is a part of the Constitution but has no legal effect independently of other parts. III. It is enforceable through Courts of Law. IV. The Objectives Resolution by Jawaharlal Nehru finally became the foundation for the Preamble. Which of the statements given above are incorrect?
- (a) I and II only
- (b) I and III only
- (c) II and IV only
- (d) III and IV only
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): only statements I and III are incorrect, because the Preamble was adopted after the rest of the Constitution and is not enforceable through courts, while statements II and IV correctly describe its constitutional status and its source in Nehru’s Objectives Resolution. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — The Preamble was adopted last, on 26 November 1949, after the rest of the Constitution had been settled and passed. It came into force along with the Constitution on 26 January 1950. So the statement that it was enacted before the entire Constitution is wrong. • ✅ II — In Kesavananda Bharati v State of Kerala (1973), the Supreme Court held that the Preamble is a part of the Constitution. But in LIC of India v Consumer Education & Research Centre (1995), the Court clarified that it has no independent legal effect: it cannot be enforced on its own. It only helps in…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 32
The objectives specified in the Preamble contain the basic structure of our Constitution. In this regard, choose the correct answer:
- (a) Basic structure means that which cannot be amended in exercise of the power under Article 368 of the Constitution.
- (b) The Preamble is not a part of the Constitution and has no legal value.
- (c) The basic structure can be amended by a simple majority in Parliament.
- (d) The objectives in the Preamble are merely directive and are non-justiciable.
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): the basic structure is precisely that part of the Constitution which Parliament cannot amend even under Article 368, because Kesavananda Bharati (1973) held that some features, including the Preamble's objectives, lie beyond the amending power. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — In Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) the Supreme Court held that Parliament's amending power under Article 368 is wide but not unlimited. Certain essential features — democracy, secularism, federalism, judicial review, and the goals of justice, liberty, equality and fraternity declared in the Preamble — form the 'basic structure'. Any amendment that damages or destroys this basic structure is void. So 'basic structure' means exactly that which cannot be amended, however large the majority, in exercise of the power under Article 368. • ❌ (B) — This carries the old view of Berubar…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 42
The Preamble may be invoked to determine the ambit of
- (a) Fundamental Rights only
- (b) Directive Principles only
- (c) Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles
- (d) Fundamental Duties
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): the Preamble is invoked to determine the ambit of both Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles, because its goals of justice, liberty, equality and fraternity are the shared foundation of Part III and Part IV alike, with Minerva Mills (1980) declaring their harmony a basic feature. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Fundamental Rights only — Partly true but incomplete. Courts have used the Preamble to read the scope of Fundamental Rights — for example, in In re Kerala Education Bill (1958), the Supreme Court drew on the Preamble's 'justice, liberty, equality, fraternity' to interpret Articles 29 and 30. But the Preamble's four ideals equally shape the Directive Principles, so limiting it to Part III alone is absurdly narrow. • ❌ (B) Directive Principles only — Again half the truth. The Preamble itself declares justice — social, economic and political — and these…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 52
Which of the following Liberties is sought to be secured to the citizens of India in the Preamble?
- (a) Thought, expression, belief, faith and worship
- (b) Social, economic and political justice
- (c) Equality of status and of opportunity
- (d) Fraternity assuring dignity of the individual
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): the Preamble's liberty clause reads exactly 'LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship', while options (B), (C) and (D) belong to the separate heads of Justice, Equality and Fraternity. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — The Preamble says it will 'secure to all its citizens ... LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship'. This is the only clause in the Preamble that appears under the head 'Liberty'. Notice the five things liberty covers — thought, expression, belief, faith and worship — which together mean freedom to think, to speak, to hold a belief, to follow a faith and to worship. Think of it this way: liberty is the 'freedom' ideal, and the Preamble lists exactly the five freedoms it has in mind. • ❌ (B) — 'Social, economic and political justice' is the JUSTICE clause of the Preamble, not the Liberty clause. Justice and liberty a…