APPSC Group-I Prelims 2024 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 48
With reference to Indian polity, which one of the following statements would you accept as appropriate ideas referring to 'Equality'?
I. The primacy of equality is safeguarded, defined and enforced by the courts of law rather than by the Constitution as conceptualized by A.V. Dicey.
II. Article 14 of the Constitution of India constitutes only the concept of 'Equality before the law' but does not mention the concept of 'Equal Protection of Laws'.
III. Article 194 and Article 361A of the Constitution of India are indicative of the fact that equality in India is not absolute.
IV. The theory of equality includes distinction of merit but not distinction on account of hereditary titles or nobility as propounded by the Balaji Raghavan Case (1995).
Select the correct answer using the codes given below:
- (a) I and III
- (b) III and IV
- (c) II and III
- (d) I and IV
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): only III and IV hold, because Articles 194 and 361A show Indian equality is not absolute, and Balaji Raghavan upholds merit-based national awards while Article 18 bans hereditary titles - while I wrongly shifts equality's source from the Constitution to the courts and II forgets that Article 14 carries both 'equality before law' and 'equal protection of laws'. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — This is A.V. Dicey's British picture, not India's. Dicey, writing about England, said the rule of law means equality before the law enforced by ordinary courts, because Britain has no written constitution. India is the opposite: equality is 'safeguarded, defined' by the Constitution itself in Articles 14 to 18, and the courts only enforce it. So placing the courts above the Constitution reverses the Indian scheme, and as an idea of Indian equality the statement fails. •…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2022 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 44
The Constitution confers which of the following Articles that denies the rights to aliens (Foreign Citizens)? I. Articles 29 and 30 II. Article 19 III. Articles 23 and 24 IV. Article 16 Choose the correct answer using the codes given below:
- (a) I, II and IV only
- (b) I and II only
- (c) II and III only
- (d) I, III and IV only
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): items I, II and IV are correct because Articles 29–30, Article 19 and Article 16 all use the word 'citizens' and so are denied to aliens, while Articles 23 and 24 in item III speak of 'persons' and apply to everyone. Statement-by-statement analysis • ✅ I — Articles 29 and 30 are cultural and educational rights. Article 29 protects 'any section of citizens' having a distinct language, script or culture, and its clause (2) says no 'citizen' shall be denied admission to State-aided institutions. Article 30 gives minorities the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Since both are framed around citizens/minorities of India, aliens cannot claim them — so this Article pair is denied to foreign citizens. • ✅ II — Article 19 lists six freedoms — speech and expression, assembly, association, movement, residence and profession. It opens wi…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 36
A person whose freedom of movement has been taken away by imprisonment or detention does not thereby lose his freedom of:
- (a) Speech
- (b) Expression
- (c) Residence
- (d) Assembly
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): imprisonment takes away the freedom of movement under Article 19(1)(d) but does not take away the freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a), as the Supreme Court held in State of Maharashtra v. Prabhakar Pandurang Sanzgiri (1966), where a detenu was allowed to write and publish a book from jail. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Speech — 'Speech' and 'expression' both sit inside the same clause, Article 19(1)(a), yet the question is built on the exact language of the Supreme Court's judgment. In custody, ordinary face-to-face speech with the outside world is heavily controlled by prison discipline (visitors' lists, interviews, no public audience), so speech is not the freedom the Court declared to survive detention. The Court's words were 'freedom of expression', not 'speech'. Hence (A) is not the keyed option. • ✅ (B) Expression — In State of Maharashtra v. Prab…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 37
Regarding the writ of Habeas Corpus, choose the wrong answer. A petition of Habeas Corpus lies:
- (a) to secure the release of a person who is unlawfully detained.
- (b) against both the State and a private individual who illegally detains a person.
- (c) against the executive authority, and is not available against private individuals.
- (d) on an application made by any person on behalf of the detenu, not necessarily the detenu himself.
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): Habeas corpus can be issued against private individuals too, so the statement that it lies only against the executive and not against private individuals is wrong. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — The core purpose of habeas corpus is to free a person held without lawful authority. Article 32 and Article 226 empower the Supreme Court and High Courts to issue it. So this statement is true. • ✅ (B) — Habeas corpus can run against both the State or executive and a private individual who illegally detains someone. For example, if a private hospital or a landlord keeps a person locked up, the court can order release. Article 21 protects personal liberty, and the writ reaches both public and private detention. • ❌ (C) — This is the wrong statement. Habeas corpus is not confined to the executive authority. It is available against private individuals too. So the claim tha…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 43
Regarding the Article 15 of the Constitution of India, find the wrong answer.
Deleted by APPSC in the final key.
Solution: The wrong statement is the one that misstates Article 15's text or history — for example, naming 'place of residence' (instead of 'place of birth') as a prohibited ground, or crediting clause (4) to the 42nd Amendment instead of the First Amendment of 1951; Article 15(1) lists only religion, race, caste, sex and place of birth, and applies to citizens alone. Statement-by-statement analysis • ✅ Grounds in Article 15(1) — Article 15(1) says the State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth — or any of them. There are exactly five grounds. 'Place of residence' is NOT one of them; Article 16(3) allows Parliament to make residence-based rules only for public employment. So any statement adding 'place of residence' or 'descent' to Article 15(1) is the wrong statement. • ✅ Citizens only — Article 15 protects 'citizens' only, wh…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 59
Due to the existence of which article, the State cannot interfere and dispossess a person's property except in accordance with the procedure established by law ?
Deleted by APPSC in the final key.
Solution: The answer is Article 300A: the State cannot dispossess anyone of property without the authority of a valid law, a safeguard inserted by the 44th Amendment Act, 1978, when property ceased to be a Fundamental Right. Statement-by-statement analysis • ✅ The governing Article — Article 300A, in Part XII, Chapter IV, says: 'No person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law.' So the State may take property only if a valid law permits it, and only by the procedure that law lays down. No law means no deprivation. Article 300 (suits against the State) sits just above it and is often confused with it. • ✅ Its status today — Article 300A is a constitutional right, not a Fundamental Right. Before 1978, property was protected by Article 19(1)(f) and Article 31. The Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978 repealed both and inserted Article 300A. Since it is outside Part I…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 144
Which of the following may be a violation of fundamental rights ?
- (a) Banning of a book
- (b) Not paying minimum wages
- (c) Prohibition of secessionist activities
- (d) Not allowing loudspeakers in a religious procession
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): the Supreme Court in the Asiad Workers case (1982) held that paying below the minimum wage is 'other similar form of forced labour' under Article 23, a direct fundamental-rights violation, while (C) and (D) are lawful restrictions and (A) is only a conditional restriction under Article 19(2). Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) — Banning a book does touch Article 19(1)(a), the freedom of speech and expression. But that freedom is not absolute. Article 19(2) allows 'reasonable restrictions' on grounds such as sovereignty and integrity of India, security of the State, public order, decency or morality, contempt of court, defamation and incitement to an offence. So a book ban is a restriction first; it becomes a violation only if it fails the 19(2) test — if it is vague, over-broad or made for a bad motive. Courts have upheld some bans and struck down others, depending o…