APPSC Group-I Prelims 2024 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 33
Which of the following State Bill/Bills will have to be mandatorily reserved for the President's consideration?
I. A Bill that proposes to give effect to certain Directive Principles of State Policy.
II. A Bill requiring prior Presidential sanction but which was however not obtained under Article 304.
III. A Bill that attracts the provisions of Article 288.
IV. A Bill seeking to operate a provision that belongs to one of the Concurrent List entries, but which is however repugnant to any Union law.
Select the correct answer using the codes given below:
- (a) Only III
- (b) I and IV
- (c) I, II and IV
- (d) I and III
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): only statement III holds, because Article 288(2) alone makes reservation for the President's consideration a condition for the State law to have any effect at all, while items I, II and IV involve a conditional immunity, a pre-introduction sanction and a permissive route to prevail respectively. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — No Article of the Constitution lays down a general rule that a Bill implementing Directive Principles must be reserved for the President. Article 31C gives protection only to laws implementing Article 39(b) and 39(c); for a State law, that protection is available only if the law was reserved and received the President's assent. Notice carefully — that is a condition for claiming immunity, not a standing command to reserve every DPSP Bill. The statement speaks of 'certain Directive Principles' in a loose, general way, so it does not fit…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2024 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 37
In the context of Centre – State Relations, which of the following statement/statements are valid ?
I. Punchhi Commission had recommended that the procedure that is followed for the removal of President should also be applicable for the impeachment of Governors as well.
II. The law that is made by the Parliament with respect to any matter in the State List in relation to the State in which President's rule is imposed, cannot be re-enacted by the State Legislature after the President's rule is ended.
III. The Sarkaria Commission was not the first to recommend the establishment of an Inter-State Council.
IV. Only the Lok Sabha can pass a resolution declaring that it is necessary in the national interest that the Parliament should make laws with respect to Goods and Services Tax.
Select the correct answer using the codes given below :
- (a) I, III and IV
- (b) I and III
- (c) II, III and IV
- (d) Only III
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: APPSC's key gave (D); the correct answer is (B) because statement I correctly reflects the Punchhi Commission's impeachment-like removal procedure for Governors and statement III is true since earlier bodies had already recommended an Inter-State Council, while II contradicts Article 357(2) and IV wrongly gives the Article 249 power to the Lok Sabha. Statement-by-statement analysis • ✅ I — The Punchhi Commission (Commission on Centre–State Relations, 2010) recommended a fixed five-year term for Governors and removal only for proven misconduct or incapacity, through a procedure comparable to the President's removal. So the statement that the President's removal procedure should also apply to Governors is in line with Punchhi's recommendation. • ❌ II — Article 357(2) says that a law made by Parliament for a State during President's rule, which Parliament could not otherwise make, contin…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2022 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 42
Which of the following entries of the Indian Constitution deals with the institutions for scientific or technical education financed by the Government of India, wholly or in part, and declared by Parliament, by law to be institutions of national importance?
- (a) Entry 62
- (b) Entry 63
- (c) Entry 64
- (d) Entry 65
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): Entry 64, because it is the only entry of the Union List that speaks exactly of institutions for scientific or technical education financed by the Government of India and declared by Parliament, by law, to be institutions of national importance. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Entry 62 — Entry 62 of the Union List covers institutions of a cultural kind — the National Library, the Indian Museum, the Imperial War Museum, the Victoria Memorial and the Indian War Memorial, plus any similar institution financed by the Government of India and declared by Parliament to be of national importance. It is about museums and libraries, not scientific or technical education. So it is the wrong shelf. • ❌ (B) Entry 63 — Entry 63 names the institutions existing at the commencement of the Constitution — the Benares Hindu University, the Aligarh Muslim University and the Delhi Univ…
APPSC Group-I Prelims 2018 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 55
The M.M. Punchhi Committee was appointed to study Centre-State relations. Regarding the Punchhi Committee recommendations, all the following statements are correct except
- (a) The National Integration Council should meet at least once a year.
- (b) The National Integration Commission shall meet once in two years.
- (c) The Governor should be given a fixed tenure of five years.
- (d) A new Article 355A may be added to deal with internal disturbances.
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): Punchhi wanted the National Integration COUNCIL to meet at least once every year — no 'National Integration Commission' meeting once in two years was ever recommended, while the annual Council meeting, the Governor's fixed five-year tenure and the proposed Article 355A are all genuine Punchhi recommendations. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — The Punchhi Commission wanted the already-existing National Integration Council (set up in 1961, chaired by the Prime Minister) to be strengthened, and said it should meet at least once every year. The idea was to convert a body that met only in a crisis into a regular forum for national integration. • ❌ (B) — Punchhi never proposed any body called the 'National Integration Commission', and never fixed a two-yearly meeting for it. The recommendation was about the National Integration Council meeting annually. Since the questi…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 30
“Cooperative Federalism” in Centre – State relations is recommended for the first time by
- (a) Sarkaria Commission
- (b) Rajamannar Commisson
- (c) Venkatachaliah Commission
- (d) M.M. Punchhi Commission
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): the Sarkaria Commission (1983–88) was the first among these commissions to formally recommend cooperative federalism in Centre–State relations. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — The Sarkaria Commission was constituted in 1983 and reported in 1988. It formally recommended cooperative federalism as the working model for Centre–State relations. It urged consultation, coordination and shared decision-making, including greater use of the Inter-State Council under Article 263. • ❌ (B) — The Rajamannar Committee was appointed in 1969 by the Tamil Nadu government. It argued for greater State autonomy and a reduced role for the Centre. It did not recommend cooperative federalism as the model for Centre–State relations. • ❌ (C) — The Venkatachaliah Commission was the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, working around 2000–2002. It discussed Centre…