APPSC Group-I Prelims 2024 — Paper-I (General Studies) · Q 38
Consider the following statements in connection with the distribution of tax revenues between the Centre and the States:
I. The proceeds of the surcharges that are levied on taxes and duties referred to in Article 269 and Article 270 of the Constitution of India, would be shared between the Centre and the States.
II. Article 268A and Article 272 of the Constitution of India were both repealed by same Constitutional Amendment Act.
III. Tax on the sale of petroleum crude is levied by the Centre but collected by the States.
IV. The net proceeds of tax categories that are falling under Article 269 of the Constitution of India, do not form a part of the Consolidated Fund of India.
Which of the above statement/statements is/are valid?
- (a) II and IV
- (b) I and III
- (c) Only IV
- (d) Only III
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): only statement IV is valid, because Article 269(2) expressly excludes Article 269 tax proceeds from the Consolidated Fund of India and assigns them to the States, while statements I, II and III misstate surcharge sharing, amendment history and petroleum sale tax levy. Statement-by-statement analysis • ❌ I — Article 271 says that Parliament may increase any duty or tax referred to in Article 269 or Article 270 by a surcharge for the purposes of the Union. The whole proceeds of such a surcharge form part of the Consolidated Fund of India. They are not shared with the States. Thus, the proceeds of surcharges are not shared between the Centre and the States. • ❌ II — Article 268A, which dealt with service tax, was omitted by the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016, which introduced GST. Article 272, which dealt with Union duties of excise distributed among States,…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 18
Which of the following parameters had the highest weightage for calculating tax devolution from Centre to States as per the recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission ?
- (a) Population
- (b) Area
- (c) Income distance
- (d) Demographic change
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): Income distance carried 50% weight, the single largest share in the 14th Finance Commission's horizontal devolution formula. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) Population — In the 14th Finance Commission formula, population as per the 1971 Census carried a weight of 17.5%. It was an important criterion, but not the highest. • ❌ (B) Area — Area had a weight of 15% in the 14th Finance Commission's horizontal devolution formula. It rewarded larger States, but was much below the 50% given to income distance. • ✅ (C) Income distance — Income distance carried the highest weight, 50%, in the 14th Finance Commission's tax devolution formula. It measures how far a State's per capita income is from the highest per capita income among large States, and thus favours relatively poorer States. • ❌ (D) Demographic change — Demographic change, that is, the change in population betwe…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 19
Which year is taken as the basis for resources for making recommendations by the 14th Finance Commission ?
- (a) 2012 – 13
- (b) 2014 – 15
- (c) 2015 – 16
- (d) No base year
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): the 14th Finance Commission used 2014-15 as the base year for its resource projections, while its recommendations applied to 2015-16 to 2019-20. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) 2012 – 13 — 2012-13 was not the base year adopted by the 14th Finance Commission for its resource projections. Its award period began later, so the Commission needed a benchmark closer to that period. • ✅ (B) 2014 – 15 — The 14th Finance Commission, chaired by Y.V. Reddy, adopted 2014-15 as the base year for its macroeconomic and fiscal projections. Its recommendations covered 2015-16 to 2019-20, so 2014-15 was the latest full-year benchmark available when the report was prepared. • ❌ (C) 2015 – 16 — 2015-16 is the first year of the 14th Finance Commission's award period, not the base year. The base year is the reference year from which projections are made; the award period is the five-yea…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 20
Which of the following is one of the factors not considered by the 14th Finance Commission in vertical devolution of resources ?
- (a) Spirit of the Constitutional provisions
- (b) Concerns of States and Centre on fiscal space
- (c) Differential levels in aspirations and expectations of the population of various States
- (d) Need for clarity on functional and expenditure responsibilities of States and Centre in the interest of sound federal fiscal relations
Official APPSC answer: (c)
Solution: The answer is (C): the 14th Finance Commission fixed vertical devolution by broad constitutional and fiscal-space considerations, not by inter-State differences in aspirations and expectations. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) — Not the answer: it was considered. The 14th Finance Commission said it was guided by the spirit of the constitutional provisions, especially Article 280, which makes the Finance Commission a balancing wheel of fiscal federalism. • ❌ (B) — Not the answer: it was considered. While raising the States' share to 42%, the Commission examined the fiscal space concerns of both the Centre and the States. Fiscal space simply means the room a government has to spend or cut taxes without destabilising its finances. • ✅ (C) — This is the answer. The 14th Finance Commission did not use 'differential levels in aspirations and expectations of the population of various States…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 21
Compositional shift from grants to tax devolution from Centre to State causes
- (a) additional fiscal burden on the Centre
- (b) increase in share of unconditional transfers to States
- (c) demand from States to increase tax rates
- (d) lack of fiscal space to carry out specific purpose transfer to States
Official APPSC answer: (b)
Solution: The answer is (B): a shift from grants to tax devolution increases the share of unconditional transfers to States, because tax devolution is formula-based and untied, while grants are often tied to specific purposes. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) — A compositional shift does not by itself create an additional fiscal burden on the Centre. The burden depends on the total size of transfers and the Centre’s overall fiscal position, not merely on whether the same money is given as tax devolution or as grants. • ✅ (B) — Tax devolution is an untied transfer: States receive a share of the divisible pool under Article 270 and the Finance Commission’s formula, without the Centre attaching scheme conditions. Grants, especially specific-purpose grants under Article 282, are often tied. So a shift from grants to tax devolution raises the share of unconditional transfers to States. • ❌ (C) — Th…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 22
The relationship in India between redistributive resource transfers from the Centre to States and various economic outcomes like per capita consumption, growth in GDP, tax revenue effort is
- (a) not determinable
- (b) positive
- (c) neutral
- (d) negative
Official APPSC answer: (d)
Solution: The answer is (D): the official key treats large redistributive transfers from the Centre as weakening States' own tax effort and fiscal discipline, so the keyed relationship is negative. Option-by-option analysis • ❌ (A) not determinable — The question asks for a direction and the official key chooses one. 'Not determinable' would fit only if no evidence or theory existed; the exam expects a definite relationship, even if debatable. • ❌ (B) positive — As per the official key, this is not the answer. The key follows the conventional caution that redistributive transfers can weaken the recipient State's own tax effort and create dependency. Note: an expert review argues the Economic Survey's India-specific analysis found a positive association with per capita consumption, GDP growth and tax effort; so (B) is defensible, but the key rejects it. • ❌ (C) neutral — Neutral means transfers…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 24
As per the rationalization of Centrally Sponsored Schemes by the Government of India, “core of the core” schemes are
- (a) Social protection and Social inclusion schemes
- (b) Schemes which are part of National Agenda
- (c) Infrastructure schemes
- (d) Digital India schemes
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): in the CSS rationalisation, 'Core of the Core' schemes were those of social protection and social inclusion, such as MGNREGA, NSAP and the SC/ST/OBC/minority umbrella schemes. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — The Sub-Group of Chief Ministers on Rationalisation of Centrally Sponsored Schemes placed a small set of schemes in the 'Core of the Core' category. These were schemes of social protection and social inclusion, meant for the poorest and most vulnerable. Examples include MGNREGA, the National Social Assistance Programme (NSAP) and umbrella schemes for SCs, STs, OBCs and minorities. • ❌ (B) — Schemes that are part of the 'National Agenda' were placed in the 'Core' category, not in 'Core of the Core'. The Core schemes were important national priority schemes, but they did not get the same protected status as Core of the Core schemes. • ❌ (C) — Infrastructure is…
APPSC Group-I Screening Test 2016 (Notification 36/2016) — General Studies & Mental Ability · Q 25
What is the meaning of competitive sub-federalism in the context of achieving targets on social and developmental goals ?
- (a) States competing against each other
- (b) Centre competing with States
- (c) States competing with Local Bodies
- (d) Local Bodies competing with Local Bodies
Official APPSC answer: (a)
Solution: The answer is (A): competitive sub-federalism means States competing against each other, because the 'sub-federal' units are the States and the competition is horizontal, not vertical against the Centre. Option-by-option analysis • ✅ (A) — In competitive sub-federalism, the units below the Union — chiefly States — compete horizontally with one another. They benchmark policies, improve social indicators, and try to attract investment. NITI Aayog's SDG India Index and State Ease of Doing Business rankings follow exactly this logic: a race among States, not a fight with the Centre. Hence 'States competing against each other' is the keyed meaning. • ❌ (B) — Centre versus States is vertical competition or conflict. It is not 'sub-federal' competition, because the contestants are not both below the Union. Indian federalism expects Centre-State cooperation through institutions such as the Fi…